CASR

Canadian
American
Strategic
Review

-
Canadian
Defence Policy,
Foreign Policy,
& Canada-US
Relations

-

 

 NATO Helicopters

 

Canada  in
Afghanistan

 

CASR Home

 

   

New NATO Allies  –  Leased Helicopters  –  Southern Afghanistan  –  March  2008

Canadian  Soldiers  need  Transport  Helicopters  This  Summer
Not  Next  Year  —  Time  to  Chat  with  Our  New  Czech  Mates?


Dianne  DeMille ,  Editor ,  Canadian  American  Strategic  Review  ( CASR )

Defence  Minister  Mackay  coyly  hints  about  his  talks  with  the  US  Defence  Dept

On 13 March 2008, Parliament will vote on the question of whether Canada's Afghan Mission will be extended  to the summer of  2011.  The primary prerequisite spelled out by the Manley Report  –  medium-lift  transport helicopters for our soldiers  –  has not yet been put in place. Our  defence  minister  is  a  purring  pussy-cat,  who  could  not  finesse a  face-saving  exit from a relationship with an ex-colleague.  Canadian  citizens are assured  that  he is talking to the seasoned Yankee traders of  the US Department of  Defence and the Boeing Corporation.

Mackay asserts that he might be able to get our soldiers some Chinooks by February 2009

Apparently, Mackay is begging for favours that were proffered by the US and declined by Canada in the past.  The entire performance  is humiliating.  It  makes our government  look ridiculous  –  too slow, too ineffective, too late.  Perhaps this is why Prime Minister Harper has made David Emerson the czar of the 'war cabinet' within the Privy Council Office.  He is more of a pit bull  than a pussy-cat. Emerson is what  is politely referred  to as an  'expediter'.


Spring Offensives and  Summertime Dangers  –  We need helicopters in Afghanistan  Now

DND has spent enough time trying to gain access to 'spare' NATO Chinooks in Afghanistan and there simply are not enough to go around. But there are medium-lift transport helicopters available within the fleets of  the newer member states of  NATO.  Poland has already offered Canada exclusive access  to two  Mi-17s operating out of  Kandahar Air Field. This generous offer helps by getting some of our soldiers up off the roads of Kandahar but it is not enough.

Canadian soldiers know the risks of those Afghan tracks where roadside IEDs are the number one cause of  CF casualties. Armoured vehicles used for patrols are designed to minimize the effects of explosions. But every CF truck used to deliver supplies on Afghan roads is also at extreme risk. The Mil helicopters in service with our Eastern European allies are quite capable of taking over some of that logistics role. If we could find a way to get some used  Mils, their flight crews, and mechanics, into southern Afghanistan right away – with guaranteed access for the CF –  then deliveries by road can be limited and the lives of  Canadian soldiers spared.

With  a  little  encouragement,  the  Czechs  may  offer  to  send  some  of  their  used  Mils

How can the loan of  NATO-manned Mil helicopters be accomplished by this summer? There are a large number of  these helicopters in service with our Eastern European allies.  Some are brand-new, other less so. The Czech Republic is willing to donate older Mi-17s [1] and  these helicopters probably represent our best hope. Canada can offer inducements to the Czechs to deploy these Mils to Kanadahar. We could defray the costs of transporting these helicopters to KAF (using our share of  SALIS, the Germany-based NATO airlift scheme) and ensure that supplies and parts reach the new Czech contingent. When the CF’s Afghanistan deployment is complete, these Czech helicopters can be left for use by the Afghan National Army (ANA). Payment could  come from  CIDA's  budget as part of  Canada's aid package  for Afghanistan.

The  NATO  Summit  in  Bucharest  is  fast  approaching  –  We  need  to  make  a  deal  now

Now is the moment  for David Emerson to shine.  Any deals signed at the  Bucharest  Summit must be hammered out in advance. Now is the time to do that. What exactly can Mr. Emerson offer the Czechs in exchange for saving Canadian lives?  Well, beyond an opportunity for the Czechs  to make a  larger  contribution  to  ISAF at comparatively little expense to themselves, the Czech government is very desirous of, but cannot yet afford, Canadian-made technology. As Minister of  International Trade, David Emerson is once again well-positioned to act as an expediter. The Czech Republic wants more Bombardier Challengers. Making such a purchase easier for the Czechs [2] is a small price for Canadian lives saved in Afghanistan this summer.


      [1]   The Afghan National Army Air Corps is currently flying three Mi-17 helicopters that
              came from the Czech Republic. More Mils were promised to Afghanistan and Canada
              is in a  position not only to help itself  but also to  help the Czechs  help Afghanistan.

      [2]   At present, the Czech government  operates a  CL-604 Challenger to fly its President
              and senior officials  to out-of-country  meetings. The Czech Republic had planned to
              replace its other two 'bizjets'  (older Yak-40s)  with additional CL-604 Challengers but
              lack of funds prevented this.  Such a deal is of obvious benefit to Canadian industry.